Hi Streeter,
First of all, please note that I am buying used rugs online based on some pictures that are posted there. So the prices that I quoted in my last mail of how much I would pay for a rug like yours are based on that assumption. Means that I am always taking a rather high risk when buying these items. You are actually seeing and touching the rug, so that is certainly worth some extra money as it comes with peace of mind. The rugs from ebay that you refer to in your post would be the high risk ones, especially given the appraisal they show which in my opinion is ridiculous for 50Raj Tabriz rugs woven on cotton. Below a link for a 10x13 Tabriz with cotton foundation with the color scheme you are after (kpsi seems to be quite wrong though, and the wool foundation is a simple typo). You will see that the seller has rugs that cost $100’000 like the appraisal from your ebay seller, but then they are of entirely different quality and signed by very famous weavers.
http://www.tableaurug.com/rugs/view/1/12/Large(9x12-10x13)/685/Pink-Benam
Anyway, for good vs very good vs excellent condition as I see it:
If you go through my posts on the forum, you will find two rugs I would classify as in excellent condition. A small Isfahan rug with asymmetric design (2 square meters) and a Nain rug (2.4 square meters). These had very few and small things that would tell me (a non expert) that they are used. Selvage and fringes look essentially new, no stains, color runs, moth damages etc.
For a rug that I would call in very good condition; the pictures below show you a Tabriz 50Raj (4 square meters). It has one corner where the color is slightly faded, and has the kilim part on one side that needs cleaning. Kilim part is no problem to clean, but it does not bother me so was left as is. The faded part is really minor, but would probably be more difficult to ‘erase’. No stains, no color runs, no moth damage.
The last rug is in good condition (as I see it); again possibly a Tabriz (50Raj, 4 square meters). One side of the rug is slightly faded (right side in the full picture). There is a small orange stain and some color run, together with a slightly darker area that seems to be where something happened. Stains and color run can possibly be fixed, the fading probably more difficult.
To come back to buying online versus seeing and touching the rug. The two rugs that I show here have very different wool quality. The black one has very nice soft wool, the other one much less so. In some older posts, the experts (I think it was KAD?) said that there are also ‘fake’ Tabriz rugs that are actually not woven in Tabriz but in some cheaper-labor regions of Iran.
Last thing, the four rugs I mention here cost me between 400 and 1200 Euro each, shipping costs from Germany to Australia included.
Hope that helps
redo
File Attachment(s):
full.jpg (1,268kb) downloaded 12 time(s). redo attached the following image(s):